hearts and minds

September 6, 2010

The Spirit Level

Filed under: Class warfare,Economics,Taxes — Hearts & Minds @ 5:35 pm

Do not overlook the essential info available in “The Spirit Level”, by Dr. Richard Wilkinson and Dr. Kate Pickett, published in the United States this year. The message of this book (which is fully documented, peer-reviewed, footnoted, and with extensive bibliography) can be boiled down for your convenience as follows:

(1) The cumulative evidence of all published, peer-reviewed academic research conducted around the world since WWII unequivocally shows that the greater the inequality of income and wealth in a nation, the worse off will that society and the well-being of its citizens be with regards to all variables that have been evaluated, such as virtually every measurable quality of health and health care, education, social cohesiveness, functionality and effectiveness of the societal infrastructure, criminal behavior and consequences, violence, level of trust and respect between persons and between segments of the population, assessments of personal happiness and security, etc. etc.

(2) Since mid-20th century, none of the many nations (and the families that live in them) focused on by the research presented in “The Spirit Level”, have been improved or strengthened by increasing the average per capita income and overall wealth of the nation. Instead, it is by decreasing the wealth disparity between citizens that all objective measures, as well as personal perceptions of well-being are improved. Very importantly, this is true for ALL segments of society. In other words, people who live in a nation with a more equitable distribution of wealth and income, including those in the top quartile of wealth and income within that country, are better off, for all measured variables, than are people (including those in the upper quartile) who live in a country with a wider disparity of wealth and income – even if the latter country actually has a higher per capita GNP! The important economic characteristic defining a nation with a healthier, better educated, stronger, safer, happier population (even among the wealthiest 25 percent!) is not its per-capita GNP (which is the traditional measure of the well-being of the people in a nation). The most important and defining characteristic of well-being is how narrow is the income and wealth gap between the rich, the middle class, and the poor. A nation with more equality is better for virtually everyone in that nation (except possibly the very few super-rich at the very “top”, who might think they can, even in the long run, escape the general adverse consequences of great disparity of wealth and income in a nation.)

(3) The United States now, and for some time, has the deepest and widest disparity of all modern industrialized nations of the world in terms of income and wealth distribution.

(4) The United States is now (and increasingly in recent years) ranked at the bottom of all modern industrialized nations, in terms of the many variables measuring quality of life.

The point of numbers (3) and (4) above, is that the United States is not an outlier. The U.S.A. is not the exception to the data that proves the rule. We are just the most extreme example of the rule that is established by this very extensive data.

This summary may not surprise every American, and you may be among those who would not be shocked by the evidence presented by this massive study of the relevant research. But the documentation, and the arguments and conclusions, can only be ignored by those hoping for and trying to make a constructive difference in our future at the risk of continuing the American descent into a completely corporate dominated plutocracy, governed for the benefit only of the super-rich and the trans-national corporations, and into an increasingly fragmented, anxious, divided, hoarding nation that is lacking in mutual trust, basic understanding, sustainability, and happiness.

The Spirit Level” is an essential resource and starting point for building solidarity and purpose around our common values. It authoritatively dispels several disastrous, pervasive myths which continue to afflict us in the United States.
Extracting and producing more gross income will not help solve our growing problems in America.
But reducing the widening disparity in wealth will do so.

Ref: Social Engineering for Wealth


  1. Thanks for this, Clyde. It is important that we really start getting serious about discussing the Class War that is going on. It is pretty one-sided right now because the 6000 people out of 6 billion who own almost everything also own the news media and the weapons and the food distribution.

    That Systems of systems is eventually going to fail, and when it does, a lot of information is going to come out that the public isn’t going to like. Call it ‘conspiracy theory’ or whatever, but there is a lot of wealth that doesn’t get exposed to us which could be used to benefit the species’ future. We really need to start wondering how the conflicts generated by wealth disparity and meanness will manifest themselves and how we intend to react to those situations.

    Investigation of the wealth leads to a lot of other cognitive dissonance for people who have believed very hard in the status of their ‘rights’, their food, their money, their government and their planet.

    The only thing that is going to work is the economics of people doing real work for each other, instead of for money that is spent outside the community. When local economies are back on solid, sustainable ground, then the government can think about how it will be able to do any more big ideas (like wars, trains, airports, etc.). At some point in the past, the powers-that-be decided they could spend money that they didn’t have by borrowing it from the future. In order to do so, they took some things for granted: cheap oil, cheap farm kids and immigrants with skills, and clean air and water. We are going into a Greater Depression without even one-tenth of the resources that were available during the ’30’s, but with 10 times the promises, and the ‘experts’ don’t have a clue…



    Comment by Dan C — September 6, 2010 @ 7:12 pm | Reply

  2. Sounds like a good read and something that ought to be read. Thanks for posting this.

    Comment by Marjie T. — November 7, 2010 @ 10:16 am | Reply

  3. […] itself, is evidence that if we allow Walker to plunder the scapegoats currently on the line, we will all become victims – lined up and picked off, one by one. The attack is widening and spreading even now – […]

    Pingback by STOP WALKER’S BILL and THE ATTACK ON THE WORKING CLASS « hearts and minds — February 25, 2011 @ 2:04 pm | Reply

  4. I was recommended this web site by means of my cousin. I aam now not sure whether this publiosh
    is witten by meaqns of him as nobody else understand such unique
    approximately my trouble. You are wonderful!
    Thank you!

    Comment by Mark Vijayan — September 16, 2019 @ 5:04 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: